Citizen Ruth
Cast :Laura Dern, Swoosie Kurtz, Kurtwood Smith, Mary Kay Place
Director :Alexander Payne
Studio :Buena Vista Home Vid
Format :Color, Closed-captioned
Released Date :December 13, 1996
DVD Released Date :March 01, 2005
Language :English (Dubbed), English (Original Language)
Audience Rating :R (Restricted)
 BUY THIS DVD FROM AMAZON

Customer Reviews
Rating
DateMarch 07, 2005
SummaryVery good satire tackling the tough topic of abortion
Content
Abortion is always a difficult topic to tackle, because its two extreme sides - pro-life and pro-choice - have a "you're either with us or against us and there's no in-between" mentality. Alexander Payne's Citizen Ruth is a political satire that does not take a stand on either side of the fence, instead choosing to remain neutral and expose the absurdities of each side.

Ruth Stoops (Laura Dern) is the very definition of troubled: an unemployed, drug-addled drifter with four children who were all taken away from her because she can't seem to get her life together. She's picked up for huffing and finds out that she's pregnant again, and the judge wants to impose a harsher sentence on her for endangering the fetus. This becomes a big news story, and soon Ruth finds herself being tugged at from both sides of the abortion issue.

Ruth is taken in first by the pro-life Norm and Gail Stoney, played by Mary Kay Place and Kurtwood Smith, whose intention it is to convince Ruth to have the baby. They want to help her get her life together, and offer her the guest room in their modest house as refuge from the sea of reporters that want the scoop on Ruth's story. All Ruth wants is to be left alone and to keep her life private. Oh, but she also wants to get high all the time to escape her life.

After Ruth has some difficulty with the Stoneys, another member of the pro-life commmitte, Diane Siegler (Swoosie Kurtz), takes Ruth in, and reveals that she is actually an undercover agent for the pro-choice force. The tug of war then kicks off in earnest, with the pro-lifers offering a large cash reward to Ruth for having the baby, and the pro-choicers attempting to match it. All the while, neither side really seems to care much about Ruth at all; they're more concerned with their own agendas.

Now, nothing I have said here indicates that this is actually a comedy, but there are several laugh-out-loud moments. However, director/co-writer Alexander Payne, in this, his first film, and his later films, never attempts to design scenarios simply to make the audience laugh. He's more concerned with exposing situations, and if comedy results, then so be it. In my opinion, it's a great way of doing comedy: make the laughs come from putting characters in situations that they would avoid if they could, but circumstances rule that there is no alternative.

It's kind of difficult to universally recommend a movie like Citizen Ruth, because of the subject matter. A lot of people will say that abortion is not something you should joke about, and I absolutely agree with them. However, if you can see past the subject of abortion and instead consider this film as a study in herd mentality, I think it can be rewarding.

Rating
DateAugust 17, 2004
Summaryfunny and serious look at a woman's right to choose
Content
Ruth Stoops is a bad mother. A drug addict, she has already given birth to four children and has been deemed unfit to parent them. When she's arrested for inhaling, she's told she's pregnant and the judge charges her with felony endangerment of a fetus. She's encouraged by a court employee to get an abortion.

From this point, Ruth bounces back and forth among the extremists in the abortion debate, first living with adamant pro-lifers, then finding shelter in a pro-choice refuge. While all the issues center around her, she is essentially a pawn in a larger war. This raises the important issue of who the victims really are in the abortion war. The humor comes from the extreme character sketchs of activists on either side of the debate as well as Ruth's unpredictable personality.

I didn't give it five stars because some of the situations were a bit over-the-top and more importantly, the critical issue of whether a woman can be held liable for damage to something still inside her body was raised but never developed.

Definitely a fun watch that will both make you laugh and think.

Rating
DateJune 07, 2004
SummaryHilarious, but unclear.
Content
Black comedy at its best. The 1996 film "Citizen Ruth" literally (and blatantly) pokes fun at the ongoing abortion debate, a subject which, in reality, isn't all that funny. Still, it draws enough laughs from its audiences to last them awhile.

Performances are all top-rate. Laura Dern is off the wall as the unbearable Ruth, and although one wants to physically harm her before the end of the film, she still keeps what it takes to keep the viewer interested throughout. Kurtwood Smith and Mary Kay Place turn in hilarity as the devout pro-lifers, as do Swoosie Kurtz and Kelly Preston on the other side of the fence. Watch for great cameos by Burt Reynolds and Hitchcock-veteran Tippi Hedren as, respectively, a creepily baby-loving televangelist and a staunchly serious women's rights activist.

The film does hilariously criticize both sides of the abortion debate, by portraying all the pro-lifers as big-haired, small-minded, "praise the lord"-shouting faux evangelists, as it portrays all the pro-choice characters as being homosexual, moon-worshipping (literally), mediagenic feminazis.

However, the film DOES has a slant, which is possibly its only flaw. The only character that doesn't reach to extremes and wants what really is best for Ruth is the pro-choice activists' bodyguard Harlan (played by the convincing M. C. Gainey), who, in all honesty, just believes in "human rights and personal freedom." Also, in the end, Ruth does essentially make her own choice, even if it is a bit skewed. Furthermore, the pro-life side is slammed much harder and more frequently than the pro-choice side. Director Alexander Payne should have made his statement more clear (that we as human beings should care for other human beings rather than just principles and issues), by picking a side of the fence to sit on rather than beating around the bush. However, the point is taken in the end, and it's entertaining along the way, on whichever side of the fence you happen to be.


Rating
DateOctober 19, 2003
SummaryRuth Stoops to Conquer
Content
Having seen ELECTION previously and now, finally, catching up with CITIZEN RUTH, I can't help getting excited about the work of filmmaker Alexander Payne. In both cases, the initial buzz on the films seemed positive, but in neither case, did I feel the need to rush right out to see them. An abortion comedy? A high school student council election used as a pretext to make a larger statement about ethics in contemporary American political lifez/ Frankly, the chances of either film being pulled off successfully did not seem so good.

But Payne and co-sreenwriter Jim Taylor succeeded beyond expectation both times out. These are films that take no prisoners. It's not surprising that in the case of RUTH, many viewers focus on the equal-opportunity skewering that both sides of the abortion debate receive. All true, but the characters are not quite the stereotypical cut-out figures that some have suggested. While Mary Kay Place as a fundamentalist pro-lifer may seem an obvious choice, and Swoosie Kurtz's performance as a radical pro-choicer may seem standard-issue at first, both the script and the individual performances are so full of deft touches and subtle embellishments, that their characters' self-contradictory humanity finally does begin to emerge.

Caught up in the abortion rights maelstrom is the hapless Ruth Stoops, a homeless drug addict and four-time pronounced unfit mother, who finds herself facing felony charges of 'fetal abuse' after a routine physical examination after a drug bust finds her pregnant once again. At least one review I found poking around the Net, suggested that the theme was getting a little "old" by the time of this film's release in 1996. The "fetal abuse" charge, however, is precisely the element that made the film au courant. The 'fetal rights' argument has been used increasingly in recent years to advance the pro-life cause.

Satire has its own special demands on actors, but turning in a multi-layered performance is not usually one of them. As suggested above, actors like Kurtz and Place are given some opportunity to do just that and you'll catch those moments if you don't blink. But in the title role Laura Dern is given that privelege throughout. Ruth is certainly slow-witted and morally immature, but Payne and Taylor wisely give her just enough self-awareness to make her interesting. And Dern does not play her too broadly. The satire takes on life around this authentic seeming character, almost despite her. CITIZEN RUTH is richer than your average cinematic satire.

Payne and Taylor are also the creative team behind ABOUT SCHMIDT, another film I missed in its theatrical run. Let's face it, it IS hard to keep up if you have a life. But now THAT one is definitely on my list of must-sees. A new film, SIDEWAYS, is currently in production. OK, next time out, I'll see that one first-run.


Rating
DateJuly 10, 2003
SummaryInteresting off-beat indie film
Content
Laura Dern is great in this social satire. The film doesn't take sides and brings up interesting questions. The script is smart and it takes you places you don't expect. Some of the minor characters might benefit from toning down a bit -- it gets a little heavy handed at times -- but still so much better and more original than most independent films. There are some great comic moments as well as poignant ones. A thought-provoking film. DVD also has an interesting commentary by Alexander Payne and Jim Taylor.
SuperiorPics.com © 2009